Post by 2old2standup2fat2try on May 8, 2009 10:06:06 GMT
The studio albums have their own poll, so this seemed like the natural thing to do. You can pick up to three albums, but that doesn't mean that you have to pick more than one. I have decided to include live compilations such as Living With The Past, but have not included Extended Versions as it is mostly made up of tracks taken from the other live albums. Also, I have not included Ian Anderson Plays The Orchestral Jethro Tull and The John Evan Band - Live '66 (sorry), as they are not, strictly speaking, Jethro Tull. So, which are your favourites? I apologise in advance for any mistakes made.
I may be the only one who will give the top spot to the ultra rare Live at Hammersmith from the 84 tour. Hands down the worst cover, hard to believe IA gave the ok on that, I truly suspect he did not see the cover. While I have been known to very much enjoy UW as an album, it still would be at or near the bottom for me of studio Tull, making the UW tour a bit of a surprise to see those songs fleshed out in live performance. (Really was not that surprised, for me live Tull is presumed to be excellent regardless of year, just a matter of degree.) My next 2 are more difficult cause it might be a 3 way tie, but 2 goes to LWTP and 3 to Live at Montreux, both of which top to bottom I see no evidence of voice problems, in fact I love the maturation of that voice and its incomparable diction and attack. The at home versions of Wondring Aloud and Life's A Long Song get me right dead center in the heart. Will the years treat us well indeed. The answer, 38 years on, seems to be sometimes. Very hard not to include the legendary, to us anyway, Bursting Out, improved considerably by the remastering.
Couldn't agree more about 1984..I think I have a boot, on cassette, which i called 'live wraps' from '84...it's boiling...hard rock and strong voice..I think there is a stretch, where they play, without a stop, the following songs, probably not in this order: Brick, Pegg solo, Skating Away, Sunday Feeling, Minstrel, locomotive Breath....I remembebr the hammersmith release being not quite as good as the concert i have, mainly cuz it jumps around the set list...but it does show how hot Tull was that fateful year.
Per usual, direct hit Steelie. I am using that cd more as a reference point to the 4 or 5 shows I have from that year, all excellent recordings, I think at least 2 from the radio. The burning instrumental Loco opener was most effective, sounded like Ian had heard some smack being said about him or sumpin, some good Ian fluterage . And yeah that run of Brick, Peggy and whatever was a hell of a ride. The only problem with that tour were the openers, each making a good case for worst ever, Whitesnake and Honeymoon Suite. Why not FC. Steeleye, John Martyn, John Renbourn? After all, our late friend John Martyn might have wanted to then go down in the audience and kick some Tullie ass. IA Probably wanted to spare them being booed by the signifigant element of Tull's US audience, who are a little impatient and want to hear some Zep or Sabs. I say give them A Raft of Penguins and sent them to bed early, without their Aqualung.
Bursting Out without a doubt. A live album from 1970 should have been made and perhaps still could be. The live part of Living In The Past is quite awesome. A whole live album from that tour would be great. I would bet that entire Carnegie Hall concert is available somewhere. Come on Ian!
maddogfagin: May 7 is the 127th day of the year (128th in leap years) in the Gregorian calendar. 238 days remain until the end of the year.
May 7, 2019 6:59:01 GMT
rabey: Hi John/bunkerfan and Steelmonkey.
May 7, 2019 23:08:40 GMT
rabey: Thanks for the interest. Unfortunately because Ian/Tull is doing his own book when I sent a request to find John I got stonewalled, even though I have a signed contract by Ian from 2013 stating I was doing a DVD version of The book. I also have had trouble
May 7, 2019 23:11:47 GMT
rabey: I guess after 5 years Ian forgot this even existed. Imean, he never even listed my book with all the other books that have been out of print for decades, yet mine and Tim S still have books in print and we're not mentioned.
May 7, 2019 23:13:11 GMT
rabey: I just get the impression that this AND having just dealt with Tull are all they care about really and it peeves me when the truth is when I first got my original contract with a US publisher to write the book with quotes on 3 other books on ELP,Crimson,
May 7, 2019 23:21:53 GMT
rabey: and YES, I contacted both Martin and Dave from AND and offered involvement in writing and photography. but Dave said no interest and martin was happy to get his photos printed just for credit. Later Daves book arrived and martin wanted 100 bucks a shot.
May 7, 2019 23:25:00 GMT
rabey: Anyway, The publisher refused the cost of photos, Martin wrote the only negative review of the book in print except for Amazon where a few stinkers stalled it's movement, but basically there was nothing advertising the book outside the UK.
May 7, 2019 23:29:01 GMT
rabey: I have to find a better way to post.
May 7, 2019 23:29:21 GMT
steelmonkey: Fights about history, public knowledge and more personally researched knowledge are pretty hard to untangle...but nothing takes away your contributions to total Tull information.
May 8, 2019 21:35:56 GMT
rabey: Very Kind, Steelmonkey!
May 9, 2019 1:33:24 GMT